Chinese Medicine Infiltrates Scientific Publishing - 10 April 2011 - Medical Chinese

Medical Chinese

英汉医学术语,拼音
Welcome Guest | RSS

AliExpress.com Product - High quality medical auscultator multifunctional double tube stethoscope hear fetal heart with accessories bagAliExpress.com Product - Xuanting Health Care Strong Efficacy Slim Patch Weight Loss Products Diet Patch Anti Cellulite Cream For Slimming Fat BurningAliExpress.com Product - FREE SHIPPING 250g White Ginseng,25g per piece,8 Years Root+Free Gift

SITE
MED-CHINESE
Statistics

Total online: 1
Guests: 1
Users: 0
free counters
Login form

Main » 2011 » April » 10 » Chinese Medicine Infiltrates Scientific Publishing
04:04
Chinese Medicine Infiltrates Scientific Publishing
So it turns out that Chinese Medicine has its own journal, published by BioMed Central, a large scientific publisher. The Chinese Medicine journal promotes, according to its own mission statement, studies of “acupuncture, Tui-na, Qi-qong, Tai Chi Quan, energy research,” and other nonsense. Tui na, for example, supposedly “affects the flow of energy by holding and pressing the body at acupressure points.”

Right. What is this doing in a scientific journal? Actually, there are plenty of garbage journals out there, and I’d ignore this one like I do the others, butBioMed Central (and their owner, Springer Science) is a respectable publisher. It’s also one of the largest open-access publishers, which means they make all their articles from their 213 journals freely available. I support BMC and I’m on the Editorial Boards for three of their journals (BMC Biology, BMC Genomics and BMC Bioinformatics). But their corporate leaders seem to care more about expanding their stable than about maintaining the integrity of science. Chinese Medicine simply does not belong in the company of respectable scientific journals.

What is “Chinese Medicine” anyway? (Should we also have journals for Russian Medicine, or American Medicine, or Swedish Medicine?) Actually, the name refers to what is usually called Traditional Chinese Medicine, or TCM. TCM is a grab-bag of superstitious practices taken from Chinese history, most of which are ineffective or even harmful. The most common justification for studying TCM (and using it on patients) is something along the lines of “this is an ancient Chinese practice” as if anything old must be worthwhile (also known as the argument from antiquity, a logical fallacy). But using the term “medicine” to describe Qi-gong, acupuncture, and “energy research” is, to put it bluntly, nonsense.

And by the way, “energy research” in this context doesn’t refer to methods for producing electricity. No, the energy research in this journal refers to mysterious energy fields in the body, stuff like the “deqi” in this article from the January 2011 issue of Chinese Medicine: “Perception of Deqi by Chinese and American acupuncturists: a pilot survey.” It’s a laughably bad study, but here’s a link for those with a high tolerance for quackery.

Ancient medicine was almost always bad medicine. People died very, very early in those good old days, and ancient China didn’t have any special secrets. Two thousand years ago, if you were lucky enough to survive past childhood, you might just make it to your 30’s. Life expectancy has climbed dramatically in recent times, for the past 150 years or so, thanks to modern hygiene and medicine. Forming a scientific journal whose goal is to validate antiquated, unproven superstitions is simply not science, whatever the editors of Chinese Medicine claim. The journal’s claim to be “evidence-based” (yes, they do claim that) is little more than a smoke screen.

BioMed Central publishes at least one other pseudoscience journal, BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine. BMC should be embarrassed to be publishing journals that promote anti-scientific theories and otherwise muddy the literature. By supporting these journals, they undermine the credibility of many excellent BMC journals. They should cut these journals loose.

Views: 1386 | Added by: Weifeng | Tags: Southern, china, medicine, asia, Europe, TCM, medical, usa, America, terms | Rating: 0.0/0
Total comments: 0
Only registered users can add comments.
[ Registration | Login ]
Choose Language
Your Vote
What do you think about TCM treatment?
Total of answers: 0
EASY REGISTRATION
Email Address *:
Phone:
Full Name *:
User Name *:
Security *:

NoteUser Name should be without any space
Note:Give valid email address
Note:Clicking on Submit Button you are agree to be bound by our Rules and Regulations
Search
Calendar
«  April 2011  »
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
     12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
Entries archive
Others
Directory Free Ldmstudio Directory Play free online chess! List My Website
Site friends
  • Medical Chinese Freebase
  • Freebase (Connect All The Knowledge)
  • Create a free website
  • Knol (A Unit of Knowledge)
  • Medical Chinese in Knol
  • Medical Chinese( NYU )
  • Chinese Medical Translation
  • English to Chinese Medical Dictionary
  • Chinese Medical Translation (various language)
  • Chinese Medical Doctor Association
  • Dr. Dict
  • Medical Dictionary Online For Chinese
  • National Medical Examination of China (English Web)
  • English-Pinyin
    herbal medicine study Doctor student pharmacy Exam cimetidine study in china abbreviation enlish terms pinyin Department education examination foreigner g-cimetidine bangladesh App hospital Bullet cancer Case Download History chinabangladomain Disease fatty health Hosting medical Anatomy teacher America asia Europe 01534668314 Brain Buy Domains gTLD appliances asian Bacteria Conditioning genetics genome Immune System china Humidifier Portable Fan flowerpot Office Traditional Flower guangzhou mini Heart chinese university Detect diabetes endocrine eye color usb Aroma lovely Encephalofluctuograph Freshener air 2013 free home TCM mbbs Guangdong Beijing 28 clip ClipsFull colour Gem Chinese 主机 购买 Human 2015 Australia bddoctors doctorsbd HealthCare android Hongkong job BEST chinajob Company Lesovir-C,Twinvir, dhaka,达卡,孟加拉, 治疗